Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Goodwyn - Populist Moment

Goodwyn, Lawrence. The Populist Moment. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1978.

Argument
The populist movement was the largest democratic mass movement in American history. Democratic is the key word for Goodwyn. Populism arose from grassroots organizing by farmers to overcome the downward economic spiral posed by the capitalists they borrowed from and sold to. It's growth was fostered through the efforts of ideologues who spread the populist message from community to community. Its significance was that it was the last major attempt to destroy the association between private capitalist businesses and the government - the corporate state.

Key Items
Sectionalism - Late 1800s politics were divided by sectionalism, with Republicans dominating the North East and business and Democrats dominating the South.
Contraction - To counter the inflation of the Civil War and revert to the gold standard, the federal government allowed a prolonged period of contraction, thus decreasing the money supply to get it back in line with the perceived value of the currency. This was the key cause of farmers' woes in this period.
Greenback Movement - A political party from 76-84, their ideas for a paper currency floating untethered from a hard currency standard were influential to the populists, and anathema to popular economic theory, which elevated a hard currency (either gold or gold and silver) as both economically and morally sound.
Farmers Alliance - (Southern, out of Texas) Fused with the Greenback Movement to become the Populist Party of the 1890s. Lecturers, such as S.O. Daws and William Lamb spread the agrarian message to organize cooperatives to try and break the stranglehold of capitalists on farmers. Goodwyn disputes older analysis (Hicks) that believed populism arose out of the Northwestern Alliance (Wisc, Minne, etc), which he says were actually hostile to populism.
Tom Watson - Typical populist leader. Argued for unity of poor farmers - black and white - against the capitalist forces oppressing them, before turning to racism after the movement's failure.
Omaha Platform - July 4, 1892. Sums up the populist program, particularly in its greenback doctrine, which merged with agrarian concerns.
Sub-treasury scheme - Populist idea to create a national source of finance for farmers, allowing them to circumvent the crop lien system and prevent them from being tied to market forces that were effectively killing them.
St. Louis Convention 1896 - Populists, fighting for political legitimacy, fused with the Democratic party and its candidate, Bryan. In fact, this would prove to be the end of the populist movement.

Saturday, April 9, 2011

Keegan - The First World War

Keegan, John. The First World War. New York: A.A. Knopf, 1999.

Argument
The First World War was a complete debacle. The Allies pursued a nightmare strategy of larger and larger annual offenses against the western front.

Western Offenses
1914 - Schlieffan Plan (through Belgium) and French Plan 17 (right into Alsace-Lorrain). Germans almost succeed, but the farther the armies go the harder it is to coordinate. The Battle of the Marnes is won by the Allies, and the race to the sea/battle of the frontiers leads to entrenchment (Germans dig in permanently to shift troops to the East)
1915 - Ypres: an attempted pincer movement with the British going from the north and the French from the South.
1916 - Verdun: The Germans hoped to draw the French into a war of attrition using massive artillery bombardment and attacks on the Verdun fortress, which the French would have to pour troops in to hold. The cost proved too high for the Germans, and thereafter they sought to defend on the West and attack on the East to drive the Russians out of the war.
The Somme: Rather than the attempts at encirclement of 14, 15, 17 and (successfully) 18, Douglas Haig sought a direct assault using a mass of troops following a creeping barrage. Let's just say it didn't work and move on.
1917 - Nivelle Offensive: Nivelle was an artillery expert, and thought a more expertly targeted barrage could lead to a breakout from Rheims to Roye (Champagne, supported by a British offensive at Arras and Vimy Ridge). Ugh.
1918 - After the Russian Revolution and chaos in the east allowed the Germans to bring their troops back to

Other Key Debacles (and some successes!)
Gallipoli - Ill-fated naval/marine battle designed to open a supply line to Russia and draw Austro-Hungarian forces away from the East.
Isonzo - Italy, led by a commander who led with fear, pursued a dozen utterly hopeless offensives against the well-defended Austro-Hungarians.
Brusilov Offensive - 1916, Russian general managed to beat back the Germans through new tactics that would be adapted by Germany in WWII
Jutland - Key naval battle: "the inmate escaped from jail, inflicted casualties, but then went back to prison"

Brinkley - Liberalism and Its Discontents

Brinkley, Alan. Liberalism and Its Discontents. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press, 1998.

Argument
Brinkley explains liberalism in a series of collected essays, suggesting the changing nature of liberalism throughout the 20th century and the resulting difficulty in pinning it down with a specific definition. Nonetheless, I'll try to synthesize a definition: liberalism is the belief that the government can improve inefficiencies in the free market to the benefit of business, while simultaneously alleviating the effects of market downturns as well as supporting the poorest members of the nation. In foreign policy, the liberal state seeks to spread both the nation's ideals and interests through a combination of diplomacy and military power.

Discontents
Chapter 1 - FDR had some serious mother issues - his mother was controlling, and he tried to resist her throughout his life. His relationship with Eleanor was professional and never intimate after she discovered his affair at the end of the 1910s. He admired TR and strove to follow in his footsteps. Polio was huge. His efforts to overcome its affects through effort and denial revealed his character. Overall, his personality was overly friendly and thus extremely evasive. It was hard to know the real FDR, and Brinkley suggests that perhaps no one ever did.
Chapter 2 - The New Deal had no core ideology. It was a series of experiments designed by the experts FDR brought in to the White House.
Chapter 3 - In 1937 many thought that the Depression was ending and it was time to roll back. The ensuing recession ended those ideas. World War II and the Cold War solidified the massive new state
Chapter 4 - The New Deal coalition made the Democratic party once again a national party. It no longer had to play the politics of race to win in the south, thus setting up JFK and LBJ to take on Civil Rights.
Chapter 7 - A helpful essay on historiography of the Interwar years.
Chapter 10 - Henry Stimson and John J. McCloy represent members of the liberal establishment: non-politicians who played a large role in the government, particularly in foreign policy.
Chapter 12 - A brief synthesis of Isserman combined with an explanation of the New Left.
Chapter 14 - After 1968, the parties sought to gain control of their political conventions, turning them from exciting, unpredictable sites of politicking to scripted, ordered declarations of the pre-ordained candidates.
Chapter 15 - Oral Roberts represents how one religious figure emphasized that American Christians could be good Christians and still pursue prosperity in America.
Chapter 16 - A helpful synthesis of American conservatism, particularly the new Reagan right.

Helpful Quote
"...[the National Resources Planning Board of World War II showed] how the "planing" ideal was shifting away from the vision of a rationally ordered economy (prominent in the early 1930s), away too from the idea ofthe activist regulatroy state (a central feature of late 1930s reform) and toward the concept of compensatory action. Planning would enable govenrment to stiumlate economic growth through fiscal policies." (p.56)

Review
http://www.jstor.org/stable/2568415
"Brinkley writes with some "skepticism about the progressive assumptions of much twentieth-century political history," an atti- tude evident in his first book, Voices of Protest (1982). There Brinkley argued that a "popu- list" resistance to centralized wealth and power, speaking on behalf of family, community, and local self-determination, survived long beyond the nineteenth century, into the 1930s, as a counterweight to the nationalizing and bu- reaucratizing trends widely assumed by liberal historians to have made the Rooseveltian wel- fare state inevitable. "The Late New Deal" similarly casts doubt on the self-assurance of liberal historians by disclosing great uncer- tainty and indeterminacy in the substance and development of liberal ideals. Amid economic and political setbacks, Brinkley finds, New Deal reformers tacked and swayed, moving away from their initial aspiration to build a new, harmonious political economy toward successively more limited visions. If thorough reconstruction was unachievable, they opted instead for a strong regulatory state fighting monopoly-before turning to a roughly Key- nesian program of government-sustained eco- nomic growth. Finally, they adopted an even more modest program trusting in the dyna- mism of capitalism itself to fund public relief and social insurance programs as mere acces- sories to the marketplace. Besides establishing a limited welfare state, Brinkley concludes, "the New Deal is also important for the op- tions it foreclosed, for the way it tried to take certain paths and failed in trying, for how it delegitimized certain concepts of the state even as it was legitimizing others."

Thursday, March 31, 2011

Keegan - The Second World War

Keegan, John. The Second World War. New York: Viking, 1990.


Argument
The Second World War killed a bunch of people all over the world. Keegan explains how.

Breakdown
He concentrates on
  • the Battle of Britain as an air battle,
  • Midway for the clash of large carrier forces,
  • Crete as an essentially airborne assault,
  • Okinawa as a representative amphibious operation, and
  • Berlin as the supreme example of a city siege and battle.
  • Falaise as a tank battle
A few quick key assessments
  • Strategic bombing did not match the hopes it inspired before the war of bringing about a quick victory
  • Espionage did not play a hugely significant role, but signals intelligence was more critical
  • Midway was a close shave that, through good fortune as much as strategy, was certainly the pivotal battle in the Pacific. To the victor belonged control of the seas.
  • Airborne assault was dicey. It only worked in Crete because the British defenders didn't realize how well they had warded off the assault on the first day, and ceded a key airstrip which the Germans exploited on the second day. It worked at Normandy because the allies learned from Crete to drop their forces away from the targeted strongpoint and then move toward it on the ground. It failed at Marketgarden because this wasn't done.
  • The second Atomic bomb was unncessary for ending the war.
  • Stalin was CONSTANTLY thinking in terms of geopolitics, and wanted to gain something from the war from the start.
  • Though they fought bravely, local resistance within Nazi territory, from France to Warsaw, was never more than a nuisance to the Germans.
  • Stalingrad was the turning point in East Europe. Hitler over extended, and then refused to allow his trapped army to fight its way out of the city.
  • Italy served Hitler in that it occupied the Allies without too much extension of German resources.
  • Hitler's main delusion in continuing the war was his Faith in his secret weapons program
  • Churchill was a master of diplomacy and managed to postpone the opening of a Western front until he felt the British army was ready to wage it. US wanted to open the front in 42, and then 43. The allies pursued a strategy of "Germany first, but not yet" after the US entered the war.

McCabe and Akass - Quality TV

McCabe, Janet, and Kim Akass. Quality TV: Contemporary American Television and Beyond. London: I.B. Tauris, 2007.

Argument
This book of essays features critics and academics agonizing over how to describe the changing characteristics of television (mainly American TV: this was created out of a conference at Trinity College, Dublin in April 2004 called "American Quality TV") without falling into the trap of making inherent value judgments. Ultimately, such a task requires a book of essays by not only professors but media and industry members, as well as interviews with David Chase and composer W. 'Snuffy' Walden (thirtysomething, among others scored).

The authors use the phrase TVIII to describe the TiVo, 21st century version of television, while TVII seems to refer to the cable version. TVIII is what Lotz might call Post-Network television. The note on page 266 confirms this: Behrins (1986) coined TVI and TVII as shorthand for network (1948-75) and post-network (1975-95). TVIII is the post-1995 version, as dubbed by Rogers, Epstein and Reeves (2002)

Robert Thompson, oft quoted throughout for his 1996 book Television's Second Golden Age, introduces the book by repeating his simple phrase "not regular" and though many characteristics are identified throughout, that remains as complete a definition for quality television that the authors can muster.

HBO looms heavily over the collection for the distance it has pushed the envelope of Quality TV first established on networks. McCabe and Akass argue that part of the pleasure of HBO comes from the power of watching a program that viewers know is naughty, even as TV watchdog groups derive pleasure from the act of critiquing HBO for its naughtiness. HBO finds it must explain the naughtiness of its shows based on artistic rationale.

Another more intriguing essay by Feuer refutes the suggestion that HBO's programming like Six Feet Under is remarkable because it has no predecesors in culture. She argues that HBO's programming is rooted in art cinema, and has developed out of quality TV. Further, she argues HBO's programming is no more original than reality TV, exploding at the same moment. The reason why it gets more artistic credit is its relationship to art cinema.

The final essay is about Lost, and also acknowledges that show's dept to film. It anticipates network dramas following in Lost's footsteps. However, we now know that Lost and 24 were anomalies in the latter half of the decade. They were never matched on the network. Instead, the quality TV revolution lives on in 30-minute comedies, not hour-long dramas.

Tuesday, March 29, 2011

Kennedy - Over Here

Kennedy, David M. Over Here: The First World War and American Society. New York: Oxford University Press, 2004 [1980].

Argument
Into WWI, Wilson led a nation that was quite divided over fighting the war. Even Congress was shocked at his decision to draft an American Expeditionary Force to take part in the fighting. Thus, George Creel's Committee on Public Information served a crucial role in propaganda. Mobilization required the growth of temporary war administrations: the Treasury, the Food Administration, and the War Industries Board. Despite the growth of government, Wilson was careful not to trample on any free market principles.

Kennedy is surprisingly dismissive of America's role in the war, emphasizing the weaknesses stemming from their lack of experience and undisciplined military leaders. In the experience of the war itself for the doughboys, most were too late and moved too swiftly to gain the disillusionment which typified the writing of European soldiers and American anti-war, neo-isolationists in the 1920s and 30s.

Part of Wilson's failure at Versailles was the political liabilities he accrued at home as a consequence of his war management. The Armistice was one of disappointment for Wilson, as well as those who believed and hoped in his idealism. The La Follette campaign for presidency in 1924 showed that progressivism had not completely lost its energy. Its labor elements had lost its cohesiveness, but the reform impulse remained, still hopeful on the possibilities of shaping a brighter future, though that future might be a few decades down the road.

Kennedy argues "make the world safe for Democracy" has remained America's foreign policy mission statement since then.

Finally, the war marked the beginning of the end of British economic supremacy, and the end of the beginning of the US economic supremacy.

Interpretations
Review: Robert D Cuff, JAH
"Kennedy suggests, moreover, that as a cultural phenomenon the war crisis reveals a number of core American social values, including a deeply rooted suspicion of concentrated public power and a bias toward voluntarism in the construction of social institutions." In other words, its about national character.

Review: John Syrett
"For Progressives...the war provided an opportunity to realize a collective identity which could later be directed at the obvious ills, like inequality, within society. It was upon these grounds that they agreed to support Wilson. And it is here, Kennedy asserts, Progressivism began to die, for Wilson had no interest in using the government for much beyond whipping up patriotism..." Kennedy seems to suggest Wilson had little vision or leadership, at least as far as the war administration-side went...he acquiesces toward the restrictions of freedom, rather than propose or deny them.

Importance for Overall Trends
Kennedy explains the growth of the government as a feature of Wilson's mobilization, not as a result of Progressivism (since so many traditional progressives opposed the war). Further, Wilson was very careful not to over-expand the federal government and the powers under the executive branch beyond a point he could afford politically. The administration "avoided unilateral exercises of government power; they sought the barest minimum of statutory bodies; the doggedly diffused administrative responsibility; they relied wherever possible on the timehonored principle of contractual agreement; and they affirmed repeatedly the temporary character of those few naked instruments of authority they were reluctantly required to grasp." (143) Still, Wilson's creations served an important precedent for FDR.

Monday, March 28, 2011

Lyotard - The Postmodern Condition

Lyotard, Jean-Francois. "The Postmodern Condition." From Alexander, Jeffrey C., and Steven Seidman. Culture and Society: Contemporary Debates. Cambridge [England]: Cambridge University Press, 1990.

Originally published 1984

Definition of Postmodern
"incredulity toward metanarratives...a product of progress in the sciences."

Argument
Postmodern condition has created a crisis in metaphilosophy and the university system that relies on it. The sciences have splintered into specialties, and the definitions between fields have become blurry.

Linguistically, because language is ever-changing and contains meaning which is individually determined, it is impossible for two people to speak with 100% understanding of the meaning each person is trying to convey.

"Consensus is a horizon that is never reached."

Connection
In some ways, I feel like Lyotard is talking about the same thing as Bell in "The End of Ideology in the West." Ideologies rely on metanarratives.