Saturday, March 19, 2011

Nye - Unembarrassed Muse

Nye, Russel B. The Unembarrassed Muse: The Popular Arts in America. New York: Dial Press, 1970.

Argument
Emerging in the mid-18th century, popular arts exploded in the 19th century from a combination of historical factors:
  • the rise of the middle-class,
  • the passing of control of the means of production and transmission from a privileged elite to the middle class,
  • rising literacy,
  • increased leisure time
  • technology for mass reproduction
Thus, in between the folk art of the masses and the elite art supported by wealthy patrons arose an art designed to be sold to a mass audience for the artist's profession. "Popular art is folk art aimed at a wider audience, in a somewhat more self-conscious attempt to fill that audience's expectations, an art more aware of the need for selling the product, more consciously adjusted to the median taste." (3)

The thick book explores the history of popular arts, or rather how various arts became popular and what sorts of themes they reveal: fiction, poetry, theatre, comics, mystery, sci-fir, westerns, popular music, movies, radio, TV. He historicizes the trends these genres go through, revealing their connection to social developments.

Popular Art Criticism
"Popular art confirms the experience of the majority, in contrast to elite art, which tends to explore the new." (4) Thus, critics have tended to view popular art negatively. Nye, writing in 1970, is somewhat ahead of the curve in insisting that popular art is not inherently bad, but rather tries to apologize for its dependence on the market. His conclusion is a useful, short synthesis of critical trends.

elitist criticism - Dwight MacDonald, Richard Hoggart. The rise of inherently bad mass culture threatens good/elite culture. Thus, creators of elite culture should band together (perhaps by government funding) and create art which resists mass culture.

Marxist criticism - Beginning in the 1930s, Marxists took an opposite view to MacDonald et al, arguing the largest problem of mass culture was its control by the elite who exploited the msses with bad art.

Gilbert Seldes led the way in attempts to refute elitist criticism. He rejoiced in particular in the potential mass culture had to communicate with everyone, critiquing mass culture only for its failure to reflect a democracy.

Marshall McCluhan provocatively raised the importance of considering the medium and the setting within which the medium is experienced for Cultural studies.

Suson Sontag, by 1966, was rejecting the distinctions of "high" and "low" art as dubious.

Apparently approving of these later developments, Nye concludes with a call for greater academic and intellectual exploration of popular culture.

Reading note
This book has a fantastic index, and its chapters are useful surveys of specific genres of popular culture.

Thursday, March 17, 2011

Smith-Rosenberg - Sex as Symbol in Victorian Purity

Smith-Rosenberg, Carol. "Sex as symbol in Victorian Purity." From Alexander, Jeffrey C., and Steven Seidman. Culture and Society: Contemporary Debates. Cambridge [England]: Cambridge University Press, 1990.

Originally published 1978

Smith-Rosenberg discusses Victorian reformers' critique of sex in writings during and after the age of Jackson. Set against the backdrop of the social changes of early industrialization (young men and women moving from agriculture to urban work), moral reformers argued pre-marital sex, promiscuity, and masturbation would cause an unhealthy release of energy. This damaged the individual and correspondingly threatened the society. Sexual behavior was seen as polluting the individual and the society. Reformers disliked young women and men going to boarding schools, which were thought to facilitate immoral behavior.

"On one level [the symbols of male moral reformers] expressed timeless fears of the power and uncontrollability of orgasms, of Oedipal conflict, of male fears and fascination with woman's sexuality and her reproductive powers. On the other hand, they provided an ideal sexual regimen for a newly urbanized middle class that had suddenly to revers the procreational practices of the past two centuries..."

Further, Smith-Rosenberg sets these fears within the cosmic system they were formulated, which perceived the threat of pollution being particularly dangerous during adolescence.

Goffman - Out-of-Frame Activity

Goffman, Erving. "Out-of-Frame Activity." From Alexander, Jeffrey C., and Steven Seidman. Culture and Society: Contemporary Debates. Cambridge [England]: Cambridge University Press, 1990.

This rather hilarious essay observes human action within particular frames. For example, a British palace guard is, while on-duty, constantly within a frame and utterly unable to do any action outside of his ritual military discipline.

Goffman also explores how, when individuals are incorporated into various frames, their existence as human machines will force them to deal with their desire to shift, scratch, yawn, cough or fart. The four ways to deal with this are 1. suppress, 2. release and treat as though it had not occurred OR ask permission to become out-of-frame, 3. Shield the release, 4. Assume liberties or ask for liberties to release.

He sets two extremes of framed activity: military parade grounds of strict discipline and board games of extremely informal framing.

Key Terms
disattend - assume a distraction to be out of frame for various reasons: 1. Profession, as a janitor in an office or a body guard standing next to a politician. 2. audience habit, as a visible stage hand, 3. audience/participant extreme engagement, soldier wounded in war disattends pain, gambler at casino disattends disturbances

connectives - Locating devices particularly in language: watching a speaker's lips move, "he said" in novels which help the hearer/reader understand the spatial arrangement. Goffman notes that these are stereotyped, but are not judged as such because they are very little seen

interaction competency - "capacity to cope with a range of disruptions - anticipated and unanticipated - while giving them the minimal apparent attention..." 112

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Saussure - Signs and Language

Saussure, Ferdinand. "Signs and Language." From Alexander, Jeffrey C., and Steven Seidman. Culture and Society: Contemporary Debates. Cambridge [England]: Cambridge University Press, 1990.

Originally published 1916. (Saussure died 1913)

The basics of semiotics:

Signs consist of signified (concept) and signifier (sound-image).

Signs are arbitrary. More specifically the relationship between the signified and the signifier (an essentially random collection of syllables/letters) is arbitrary.

The signifier is linear. A word only functions as a sign if you read it/say it in the linear way it is meant to be said.

The sign is immutable. No one can consciously create a sign. Language is handed down from the past.

The sign is mutable. Time change the sign as long as it perpetuates.

Thus, the principle of general semiology: "continuity in time is coupled to change in time."

Gramsci - Culture and Ideological Hegemony

Gramsci, Antonio. "Culture and Ideological Hegemony." From Alexander, Jeffrey C., and Steven Seidman. Culture and Society: Contemporary Debates. Cambridge [England]: Cambridge University Press, 1990.

Everyone is a philosopher, says Gramsci, because 1. everyone uses language which is filled with deep meaning 2. everyone has more or less "common sense" and "good sense" and 3. everyone operates on a system of beliefs: religion, superstitions, opinions, etc. From there, Gramsci notes that humans construct their philosophy based on their particular social grouping, responding to the problems of their specific reality.

Gramsci comes to conclude that intellectual elites inevitably rise to organize their specific group sharing their philosophy because of their critical self-consciousness. This is how political parties form - leaders are chosen from among and by elites based on practical and theoretical criteria.

Warshow - The Immediate Experience

Warshow, Robert. The Immediate Experience; Movies, Comics, Theatre & Other Aspects of Popular Culture. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday, 1962. (Essays written between 1946-55)

Argument
This is a collection of essays dipping in to various aspects of popular culture in a very plain, Orwell-like (as Lionel Trilling's Intro compares him) style. It's hard to come up with an overall assessment of Warshow, but the preface hints at some ideas...

Popular culture is an "unresolved problem" for critics, in which film stands at the center. Warshow sees two types of film criticism. First, older critics attempted to define an aesthetic for film that placed it equal to older arts (see Arnheim, Kracauer). Second, more recent critics began to minimize or ignore aesthetic questions in favor of exploring films as "indexes to mass psychology." Warshow is unsatisfied with both approaches based on the observations that
  • he enjoys movies,
  • he often enjoys bad movies and is more likely to find a good movie boring,
  • he goes to the movies without the expectation of finding what impulses are moving "the audience" although he may inadvertently discover this
  • The impulse that drives him to go see a "Bogart" film is not the same as the one that drives him to a "Henry James novel" or "TS Eliot poem", yet there is certainly some connection between them. (Artistic difference perhaps hierarchical yet accepts that they are all forms of "art.")
I suppose the title gets at the idea that Warshow is more interested in the enjoyment/experience of popular culture rather than the extended reflection on popular culture that critics engage in long after it has been consumed. Also, the vast majority of his essays do not attempt to address something he has not personally and directly experienced.

Importantly, Warshow was willing to take a broad array of popular culture seriously, thus setting him at the cutting edge of popular culture studies.

Possible Further Reading:
http://www.jstor.org/stable/432307
"Pursuing the Popular" by Timothy Gould, 1999. Looks at Warshow and Walter Benjamin among others.

McCarraher - Christian Critics

McCarraher, Eugene. Christian Critics: Religion and the Impasse in Modern American Social Thought. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 2000.

Argument
Compared to the ultimately satisfying slog that was Phillip Rieff and even the similarly-conceived Luker, this was disappointing. It is essentially a historiographic synthesis of what various Christian social critics were writing and saying throughout the 20th century. Luker does the same, however Luker is much easier to pin down a central argument.

Still, Christian Critics fits usefully in my reading list. It picks up the strain of "social gospel" religious thought discussed by Luker (while Luker focuses on the failure of the social gospel to pursue racial change, McCarraher returns to a broader discussion of social gospel) and continues it up to the 1970s. McCarraher reveals how Christian intellectuals of the left gradually had their religious theology eroded as they struggled to adjust their ideas to the political developments of the century as well as the deeper cultural revolution epitomized by Freud in the early century, discussed by Rieff in the 50s and 60s, and reflected on by Lasch and Bell in the 70s.

Chapters
The chronological organization helpfully roots developments in Christian Criticism within political developments.

Chapter 1 - Liberal Protestantism, Roman Catholicism, and the Social Gospel of the Professional-Managerial Class, 1900-1919 - Along with secular Progressives, liberal Protestant social gospelers looked to the professional middle class as the vanguard of social progress. Meanwhile, American Roman Catholics pursued "modern medievalism" that sought to assimilate Catholics into the corporate order, which would hopefully become decentralized.

Chapter 2 - After Such Knowledge: The Modern Temper and he Social Gospel, 1919-1932 - In the wake of WWI Social Gospelers preserved the pre-war ideals more faithfully than secular bretheren.

Chapter 3 - The Permanent Revolution: Christianity, Moral Economy, and Revolutionary Symbolism, 1932-1941 - Perception of Christianity as a permanent revolution designed to build the Kingdom of God. This led many Christian Critics to embrace Christian communism as an ideology...of course, this came to an abrupt end after WWII.

Chapter 4 - Rendering Unto Casar: The American Century, the Covenant of Containment, and the Gospel of Personalism, 1941-1962 - Led by Reinhold Niebuhr, religious intellectuals lined up behind the Cold War state against the atheism of the Soviet Union.

Chapter 5 - The Gospel of Eros: Paul Tillich, the Consuming Vision, and the Therapeutic Ethos - Tillich represents a contradictory figure of an intellectual who encouraged a therapeutic use of Religion while at the same time pursuing a rather hedonistic life.

Chapter 6 - The Twilight of the Gods: The Rise and Fall of the Secular City, 1962-1975 - Just as Isserman notes the Old Left was both hopeful of the potential of the New Left but disappointed that they weren't a larger part of it, so too did Christian Critics feel mixed about a movement that echoed much of their thought while at the same time being explicitly anti-religious.

Review

Robert Booth Fowler - JAH - http://www.jstor.org/stable/2675224

"...Reinhold Niebuhr, whom McCarraher attacks for offering no religious alternatives to the United States and in the end surrendering to the "professional and managerial culture" as his "realistic ideal"..."

"Christian Critics is also an argument grounded in left politics but hardly that of the conventional American Left. For McCarraher, the needed critique of American capitalism and its political and cultural expressions should take a distinctly religious (Christian in this instance) form and must be reconnected with the American people. For him, the Left of today is something of an embarassment. So much of what it has to say is really "moral libertarianism," and it adopts a market model for morality that hardly facilitates a serious critique of capitalism. The Left, moreover, whether secular or religious, suffers from "the lack of popular American roots." The answer, for McCarraher, is a transformative religious left connected with real people and actual institutions."