Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Dyer - Stereotyping

Dyer, Richard. “Stereotyping.” From Gays and Film. New York: Zoetrope, 1984.

Centrally, Dyer is arguing that stereotypes serve the dominant hegemony by reinforcing their position and values against potentially problematic groups.

Dyer notes that merely attacking stereotypes by saying they are wrong falls short. Often they contain truth within them, and even motivate the people they are describing to behave in line with them.
"What we should be attacking in stereotypes is the attempt of heterosexual society to define us for ourselves, in terms that inevitably fall short of the 'ideal' of heterosexuality (that is, taken to be the norm of being human), and to pass this definition off as necessary and natural." (31)

Iconography - works as a shorthand to place a character. For gays it is particularly significant because gayness is not so easily apparent as race.

The function of the character within the film's structure emphasizes stereotypes. Dyer points out examples of how heterosexual structures inevitably remain intact, even in the most critically feminist films.

Dyer discusses how the further a character moves from type the more it is a character. This draws from novels with, under the aesthetic ideal of realism, characters situated in a particular time and place rather than based on history or historic type (archetype). He acknowledges that the attempt to play gays as characters is progressive and has value, but is ultimately problematic in that it prevents solidarity between the individual and his/her sex caste. Ex. Dog Day Afternoon, Pacino's character never identifies with the painted gay activists outside. The solution to his personality issue is bank robbing. This reminds me of Siegfried Kracauer's insistence that the aesthetic essence of film is realism.

[I wonder, then, if a film like Milk is massively significant, because it's realism comes from an actual historic person rather than a created character.]

Member types - "linked to historically and culturally specific and determined social groups or classs and their praxes, which are almost bound to be outside the present cultural hegemony..." (37)

Geertz - Notes on the Balinese Cockfight

Geertz, Clifford. “Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight.” From The Interpretation of Cultures: Selected Essays. New York: Basic Books, 1973.

Geertz examines the Balinese Cockfight, from the ritual actions involved, to the masculinity issues, to the gambling, ultimately revealing it to be a site for inter-personal and inter-familiar relations to be on symbolic display.

Definition of Culture
"Like any art form...the cockfight renders ordinary, everyday experience comprehensible by presenting it in terms of acts and objects which have had their practical consequences removed and been reduced (or, if you prefer, raised) to the level of sheer appearances, where their meaning can be more powerfully articulated and more exactly perceived." (443)

I like this definition because it engages with my own interest in sports, although the Cockfight is working on a more personal level while American sports operates between much larger communities. The cockfight is not itself an obvious text, but when Geertz submits it to his search for a thick description, it reveals symbolic meaning injected by humans and reflecting the social interplay of Balinese people and villages.

Lotz - Television Will Be Revolutionized

Lotz, Amanda D. The Television Will Be Revolutionized. New York: New York University Press, 2007.

Argument
Television has moved from the Network stage (1952-81), to the Multi-Channel Transitional Stage (1981-2000), to the Post-Network Era. Lotz argues not that networks will disappear or even won't remain the most important channels, but rather will have to evolve to their rapidly diminishing place on television. Similarly, she argues that television won't go away as a cultural concept but rather that the meaning of television has changed.

Ex. The answer to "What's on television?" Network stage: 3 scheduled choices designed for mass appeal. Multi-Channel Transitional Stage: multiple cable "flows" to surf through. Post-Network Era: liberated from schedule, what's on television might mean what is literally recorded on the DVR (or DVDs, or YouTube, or VOD, etc)

Lotz's discussion is interesting though not surprising for someone who has taken two BT courses on TV post-1980. This would make an excellent book for a television history course. It's chapters cover changes in technology of TV (2), changes in production (3), changes in distribution (4), changes in advertising (5), changes in measuring audience (6), and changes in storytelling possibilities (7).

Connections
One of my favorite thing Lotz does is briefly recognize how media theories about television have had to continually evolve as the medium itself has evolved. Raymond Williams's "flow" is no longer applicable when commercials are so easily skipped. Television as a mass medium has been fractured into niches. Still, at the close, she holds that Horace Newcomb's conclusion that "intimacy, continuity, and history were the elements that distinguished television and earned its status as popular art" still holds true, in transformed but somewhat more pronounced ways. (265)

Monday, March 14, 2011

Luker - Social Gospel in Black and White

Luker, Ralph. The Social Gospel in Black and White: American Racial Reform, 1885-1912. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1991.

Argument
Luker is disputing the common perception of social Christianity into and during the Progressive Era which "suggests that, preoccupied with the ills of the new industrial order, the prophets of social Christianity either ignored or betrayed the freedmen and left their fortunes in the hands of a hostile white South." (2) Luker, of course, doesn't disagree that blacks were left behind in the reforms of the Progressive Era. He does seek to complicate the idea that social gospel proponents "ignored or betrayed" racial issues.

Luker offers several explanations for why conservative racial strategies of reform were in crisis:
  1. The decline of the previously crucial home missions movement. Handicapped by financial crisis of 1890s and replaced by a more secularized education movement after 1900.
  2. While social gospel prophets believed select missionaries should look to Africa, they rejected African colonization as a way to alleviate racial problems as a cruel hoax upon black Americans (largely out of a racialized imperialist view of the "dark continent").
  3. Central to a large part of Luker's book is the debate within social Christianity over whether the franchise was a natural right, whether education (Booker T. Washington) or franchise (WEB DuBois) should have priority [with education winning out], and whether federal or state action was better suited to fix Southern politics (with state winning out).
In the face of broad setbacks, particularly the continuing widespread horror of lynching, many reformers threw up their hands and trusted that God's justice would overcome in time.

In the beginning of his book, Luker shows how during Reconstruction northern white carpetbagger-like social gospel prophets sought to remake the south - black and white - in the image of the north.

Key Term
social gospel - H.P. Douglass was one of the first to use it. "referring generally to a fresh application of the insights of the Christian faith to pressing problems of the social order, it gained widespread circulation among contemporary religious reformers. In retrospect historians have used it to describe late nineteenth- and early twentieth-century Christian efforts to address the social problems of the age, which they see as functions of urban and industrial growth." (1-2)

Theologies of Race Relations - Chapter 10
After winding through the history of his period, Luker spends a chapter discussing 5 figures who exemplify different theological perspectives of race:
  1. Josiah Strong, radical cultural assimilationist: prominent in the movement, Strong saw Anglo-Saxon as not so much a racial category but as a more culturally pure group, and thus as the superior group for pursuing God's Kingdom. The church should acknowledge current realities, and support separate institutions in black communities, condemn racial violence, and insist on equality before the law.
  2. Josiah Royce, conservative cultural assimilationist: believed all humans were fallen, yet beloved of God and all humanity was part of the Body of Christ. There was no inherent different in races, rather race antipathy was a "childish phenomena."
  3. Edgar Gardner Murphy, conservative racial separatist: differentiated between race hatred (negative) and race antipathy (positive and natural). For both races to realize their full potential they must dwell separately. Because of their racial history of slavery, blacks needed to be educated first before they could participate fully in American democracy.
  4. Thomas Dixon, radical racial separatist: Wrote The Clansman, the basis for Griffith's Birth of a Nation. Initially highly paternalistic view toward blacks, an inferior race which should be disfranchised until they are educated enough to participate in Democracy. Eventually became more radical in his novels, suggesting that the only alternative to race war and black extermination was to send blacks back to Africa. Thus echoing the tenor of many at the time, Dixon was the most prominent of all on this list.
  5. Harlan Paul Douglass, racial transformationist: The race problem was a test of humanity's capacity to overcome racial bigotry. Douglass was aware of growing evidence that racial differences were environmental, not heredity. And besides, even if it did that was no reason why humans pursuing God's purpose should not seek justice for all humanity. Quoting the Sermon on the Mount, Douglass wondered what profit it would be for the Anglo-Saxon to gain the world but lose its soul for lack of loving his black brothers and sisters.
Connections
The fits nicely before McCarraher's Christian Critics. It also somewhat overlaps Lear's No Place of Grace, although (without referring to my notes) I remember Lear's book transcending religious ideas to a broader cultural moment of anti-modern ideas.

Kracauer - Theory of Film

Kracauer, Siegfried. Theory of Film; The Redemption of Physical Reality. New York: Oxford University Press, 1960.

Argument
As the subtitle suggests, Kracauer believes the essential aesthetic appeal of film is its ability to record and reveal reality. It thus follows in the fashion of photography, adding the critical aspect of movement to photo's stillness. Kracauer argues for a broad definition of art to allow for media, such as painting, which explores imagination to its fullest extent along with film and photography, which reveal reality to us.

He positions Melies's imagination as the antithesis to Lumiere's thesis, brushing aside Melies's commercial success as appealing to the demands of the public, not necessarily using film to its fullest aesthetic potential.

Kracauer also engages with experimental film from avant-garde. These gravitate toward the spirit of modern painting or literature, which smothers reality. However, he does acknowledge the debt film in general owes to experimental in terms of cinematic devices.

Kracauer compares the film to the novel in terms of their efforts to render life in fullness, as well as their aspiration of a sense of endlessness ( in time beyond the beginning or ending of the story, and in space beyond the world portrayed within the story). He also notes certain novels are easier to adapt: those in which the plot and character development occur through action rather than exposition of mental thoughtlife of characters.

Key term
formative - the aspects of film which the filmmaker can use to adjust the reality of what is being recorded...because the formative aspects of film far exceed those of the photographer, the filmmaker may push the bounds of the art all the way towards abstraction. Kracauer, needless to say, doesn't love this.

Feuer - Seeing Through the Eighties

Feuer, Jane. Seeing Through the Eighties: Television and Reaganism. Durham: Duke University Press, 1995.

Argument
The contradictions in Reaganism of populism/elitism played out in the television of the period. In fact, the victory of Reaganism in the period came from the fact that left critics of television read programs from Dynasty to thirtysomething as presenting a dominant ideology, when in fact a closer reading reveals contradictions within them. Feuer's examination of these programs reveals a variety of subversive readings existing among fans of these shows. Her conclusion is that the left during the 80s failed to recognize the instability of Reaganism - her book is an attempt to belatedly reveal this instability.

She cautions against dismissing these programs as either "mere entertainment" or purely pro-Reaganism texts. She undermines these hasty assumptions not only with an examination of the shows as texts (within their flow, a la BT), but also looks at the promotional tie-ins and related "nonstory materials."

Nitty Gritty
Dynasty - The common perception which Feuer seeks to undermine places the show as a mere glorification of white heterosexual male excess. In fact, Feuer notes the two demographics that made up the strongest fan base for the show were heterosexual females and homosexual males (whose cultural identity was partly formed out of a co-opting of heterosexual female dress). These groups were attracted to the camp factor of the show's women. Thus, while Dynasty fan parties often saw viewers dressing up in second-hand clothing to mimick the style of the characters, an actual Dynasty consumer line was never a success. Feuer notes that from the very beginning the show's creators were aware of the camp aspect of their show, and thus consciously pursued excess melodrama in their plots. In this way, Dynasty thus became even more popular than its sister-show Dallas.

thirtysomething - Feuer points out that no one ever claimed to be a yuppie; it was a derogatory term for others, and it reflected the way thirtysomething became "the show you love to hate." She suggests the aesthetic of the show is "yuppie guilt," which stretches back to 1983's The Big Chill. It is a contradictory show, though, because even as the characters wrestle with the guilt of their compromised baby-boomer radicalism, they find contentment in the "nuclear family" made up of their social network of friends.

postmodernism - thirtysomething, Moonlighting, Miami Vice, and Max Headroom were declared to be cinematic in various ways and thus followed in the footsteps of ultimately modernist, self-reflexive cinema such as Woody Allen. However, they are postmodern because, as ad-driven TV shows situated within the flow of the medium they are referencing, they are simultaneously complicit with and critical of television.

LA Law - Also provides a yuppie for fans to "love to hate" in Arnie Becker. Feuer uses a sequence that seems to celebrate Arnie's yuppie California lifestyle (fancy apartment, fancy cars, corporate wardrobe) but ends with his secretary Roxanne noting the opposite, dark side of the Cal life, undermining Arnie's claim that life is figured out.

Trauma Drama - Realist made-for-TV dramas of the 80s went through a particular form that mirrored both the geographic and the ideological landscape of Reaganism (Sunbelt, Farm Belt, the west -populism, anti-govt, pro-family)...
  1. Family represents ideal and norm of happy American life
  2. Trauma occurs
  3. Victims/parents seek help through institutions
  4. Institutions fail to help
  5. Victims take matters into their own hands
  6. Join a self-help group or form a grassroots organization
  7. New organization is better than established institutions
  8. Normality is restored
Feuer notes that populism is not inherently right-wing, and raises a few examples of trauma dramas that retain a left-wing criticism.

Connections
Feuer disagrees with John Fiske's formulation of the relationship between politics and entertainment. Rather than merely seeing subordinate groups making a "resistive" reading of the dominant ideology, she sees them making a "subordinate" reading, which may not necessarily please left-wing critics. In an era when all but white male businessmen could be seen to be subordinate to the Reagan hegemony, this would explain how subordinates might read television shows like Dynasty without a resistance to Reaganism.

Interestingly, Feuer notes that the rise of Hall's theories of negotiated and oppositional reading (more broadly, a shift from theories of text to theories of audience) coincided with the Reaganism/Thatcherism hegemony, suggesting a sort of wishful thinking on the part of leftist critics during a period when they felt helpless to influence the production side. Feuer thus historicizes her project, suggesting a "silent majority" (from Jean Baudrillard) powerless to influence the production yet still able to quietly make a resistive reading. (A la Dynasty's camp reading.)

Saturday, March 12, 2011

Isserman - If I Had a Hammer

Isserman, Maurice. If I Had a Hammer--: The Death of the Old Left and the Birth of the New Left. New York: Basic Books, 1987.

Argument
Isserman connects the popular front of the 1930s with the New Left of the 1960s, finding a small group of radicals still operating through McCarthyism, and thus rejecting the claim that McCarthyism killed the Left off.

The short book works through 5 chapters. The first looks at the decline of the Old Left, with the last tying the middle chapters to the rise of the New Left, mainly SDS. In between, Isserman traces three lasting strains of radicalism from the Old Left through the 40s and 50s:
  1. The continued tradition of political party, represented by Max Schactman, the head of the Independent Socialist League who swung first to the left, then back towards the center in an attempt to find a broader appeal.
  2. The continued tradition of political journal, represented by Irving Howe's Dissent. Howe was a generation younger than Schactman. He looked up to the older socialist, but pursued the spread of radical ideas through the journal, rather than through group organization.
  3. The much older American tradition of anarcho-pacifism (Thoreau to Gandhi, pre-existing but rejuvenated and inspired by MLK), represented by a variety of activists, notably the Golden Rule expedition - the attempt to sail a small boat into the range of a Pacific Ocean nuclear test.
Isserman conducted numerous interviews, and thus his book is heavy on the stories of individuals involved in the movement. Eventually, this leads to his main critique of SDS's failures. It's young leadership, though inspired and influenced by the descendants of the Old Left, failed to learn from their mistakes. Overall, neither the young students nor the relatively older left who came of age in the interim between the Old Left and the New Left were able to form a mass movement that could both appeal to a mass audience and actually have a coherent purpose behind it.

Yet, despite this focus on individual roles in the movement, it is striking how the historical turns of the Left in the 40s and 50s (and, as briefly noted, in the 60s) were affected by broader historic events. It seems the left never could quite get its legs to stand against various waves of history...
  • The Nazi-Soviet pact devastated American communists.
  • The WWII alliance with the Soviet Union, conversely, helped communists.
  • On the other hand, WWII devastated American pacifists
  • The Cold War and the quick rise of McCarthyism devastated everyone on the Left.
  • The Feb 1956 Twentieth Congress of the Soviet Communist Party in Moscow devastated the remnant of communism in the United States for Khrushchev's attack on the "cult of personality," a veiled admission of Stalin's abuses. Stalin and the Soviet Union had been, to that point, unassailable examples to US communists.
  • The Nov 1956 Hungarian revolution further eroded US communist faith in the Soviet Union. From there, American socialists took on an anti-communist tack, seeing both the Soviet Union and the United States as culpable Imperial powers.
  • The pacifist movement struggled after WWII, but began to take energy and motivation from the Civil Right's movement. By the 1960s, the pacifists managed to gain some sympathy with the general public for their anti-Nuclear weapons efforts, though bolder critiques of American military were not acceptable to most Americans.
The 1960s, on the other hand, provided fertile events for the Left to attract members...perhaps TOO fertile:
"Whenever SDS's growth slowed, another massive new stimulus came along, leading to still another exponential increase in SDS membership. The Cuban missile crisis, Birmingham, Neshoba County, Berkeley, Selma, Watts, the bombing of North Vietnam, Detroit, Newark, the Tet offensive, the May 1968 uprising in Paris, King's assassination - all fed a sense of outrage, a sense of moving with the tide of history... but gave no occasion for introspection..." (218)

Critique
As the JAH review by Michael Wreszin points out (http://www.jstor.org/stable/1889789), the main flaw of Isserman's attempted connection is the rejection of orthodoxies and political party lines by the Port Huron statement and the accompanying celebration of individual autonomy and demand for explicit moral values.

See also, a broader historiographic review "Whose New Left" by Winifried Breines, which considers Isserman along with Gitlin's The Sixties and 3 other books: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1887869

Place among other Books
Isserman connects the history of America's left from Denning's The Cultural Front, describing cultural evidence for who the left was in the 1930s, to Gitlin's The Whole World is Watching, which explains the demise of the New Left through an analysis of how the movement was portrayed to Americans by mass media. Isserman, a half-generation younger than Gitlin, was a member of the SDS as a freshman in 1968. Isserman, likes Gitlin, faults the amorphous leadership of SDS for the movement's inability to sustain itself beyond the late 1960s.